The American Society of Farm Managers and Rural Appraisers (ASFMRA) held its regional meeting this week at the brand-new AVA Hotel in Paso Robles, bringing together agricultural real estate professionals, appraisers, and economists to share insight on current market dynamics shaping California farmland.
Water Realities and Evolving Land Use
One of the strongest themes of the day was water—or more accurately, the lack of it. Experts emphasized that some regions simply “have no surface water, and never will.” Once-prolific orchard areas have dried up, leaving landowners to reimagine the highest and best use of their properties. Orchards are now viewed as water plays rather than permanent investments.
Even in areas still enjoying reliable water delivery, the economics are shifting. In the South Valley, prime water areas are seeing values near $45,000 per acre for nut orchards, though prices are softening as input and commodity costs rise. Dual-source water systems remain highly valued, and some relief has come from Waste Discharge Requirements (WDR) programs, which have given hope to regions struggling with quality and supply concerns.
Yet, subsidence remains a major issue—both as a physical and financial risk factor. Mapping and mitigating “critical infrastructure” affected by subsidence was highlighted as a priority by 2030.
Commodity Insights: Vineyards, Citrus, and Cattle
The vineyard market remains active but cautious. Eight vineyard sales were noted, with several transactions driven by non-vineyard redevelopment plans. Values are stabilizing around $28,000–$29,500 per acre, but continued viability depends heavily on low-cost water access.
In citrus, top-end demand varieties in the southern valley continue to perform well heading into 2024–2025, while in cattle, calf prices are strong at $950–$1,100 per head—reflecting ongoing demand stability.
Across markets, seller financing has reemerged as a valuable tool for getting deals done, with interest rates around 5.5% making marginal transactions pencil out. As one speaker put it, even a quarter-point drop in rates can make the difference between a sale and a hold.
Regional Market Notes: Lodi and the Delta
According to Jamie Gatzman of Oakdale (Region 3), who has been in the business for 20 years, the Lodi region has seen slight improvement in wine grape markets, though softening continues at a slower pace. Rural home sites have increased in value, with commercial land trading between $18,400 and $22,000 per acre.
Conversely, bare land sales are trending lower—some pending sales are below $10,000 per acre. Much of the Delta activity centers around conservation easements, where sellers transfer development credits to developers and sell properties with easements intact.
Case Study: Leasehold Orchard Appraisal Challenges
A fascinating case study highlighted the complexity of leasehold appraisals. One example involved a 1,700-acre orchard with 20 years left on a 30-year lease. With removal costs projected at $2,727 per acre in 2024, appraisers emphasized the need to account for a “sinking fund factor”—a reserve built over time to fund large end-of-lease expenses.
This underscores how orchard removal, inflation-indexed rent structures, and “safe rate” savings assumptions (e.g., 5%) can all profoundly affect value modeling and long-term cash flow projections.
Conservation Easements and Land Trust Considerations
The session also delved into land conservancy strategies, driven by both philosophical motives and financial incentives. Speakers covered how city, county, and state agencies—along with private land trusts and civil engineering partners—collaborate under the oversight of the Land Trust Alliance (LTA).
The IRS plays a key gatekeeping role, particularly for significant-value easements that qualify as charitable donations. Legal experts cautioned against real estate syndicate structures, which are now considered “listed transactions” by the IRS. Appraisers were advised to avoid acting as material advisors in these arrangements to mitigate legal exposure.
The San Geronimo Ranch case illustrated this point: a 900-acre coastal estate under easement experienced a 25–30% reduction in market value, yet retained strong desirability due to location, ocean views, and estate appeal.
Looking Ahead: Data, Risk, and Adaptation
The discussions made clear that California’s agricultural value equation is being rewritten—driven by water availability, regulatory evolution, and adaptive reuse.
As one speaker noted, appraisers and investors must “stretch beyond what is known and make a judgment call” when assessing risk premiums for subsidence, groundwater sustainability, and regulatory uncertainty.
By combining data-driven analysis with local expertise, the industry continues to navigate this complex landscape—balancing today’s realities with tomorrow’s opportunities.
Click here to Join our exclusive market insights newsletter.
